Just in time for 4th of July weekend, the Montauk Monster has made its return to the shores of Long Island washing up at Gurney’s Inn. (Oceanside resort located in Montauk, NY) The initial discovery was made by PJ Monte and friends while walking on beach property owned by Gurney’s Inn. (July 2nd 2009 at 6:15 PM) The dead and bloated carcass washed up during an elegant oceanfront wedding. With gorgeous views of the Atlantic Ocean it’s no surprise that the Montauk Monster decided to crash the party!
As for the wedding party, the carcass went undetected as PJ Monte and friends moved it to a different location and the photography session began shortly after. Now you are probably wondering how once again I made it to the eye of the storm to cover the breaking news. Allow me to give you the play-by-play.

While on Facebook this evening, I saw an update on PJ Monte’s wall indicating that he found The Montauk Monster as he uploaded photographs to his Flickr account. Yours truly, (Nicky Papers!) is connected to PJ through mutual friends. (God bless social networking!) Within 10 minutes of PJ’s wall posting I was able to get in touch with him by phone and explained that I was interested in covering the story. PJ graciously accepted my wishes and invited me to come out Gurney’s to check it out for myself.
With excitement, I rallied out to Montauk to once again get an up-close-and-personal encounter with the Montauk Monster. Upon arrival at Gurney’s Inn, PJ introduced me to his friends and his father Paul Monte. (General Manager, Gurney’s Inn) Paul Monte led the way as I was taken to a remote part of the property to witness the beast again with my own eyes.
The monster was removed from an ice-filled enclosure and laid out for all to view. The stench this time was so horrific it triggered my gag reflex and I was forced to take a step back. PJ and the crew lifted their shirts over their noses for relief from the rotting stench.
Sure enough, we were all looking at a very similar creature that has now washed up for the fourth documented time by photograph. For those who’ve doubted my discoveries, (Geraldo Rivera, Doug Kennedy) please note that I was with company who have openly revealed themselves and are willing to discuss this incident further.
After the viewing session we loaded the carcass back into the ice-filled enclosure for safe keeping. PJ Monte had to make an early exit as he was on his way to a party that evening in the Hamptons. My discussions with Paul Monte continued with his assistant Kon in an office located on the premises. Paul Monte agreed to run the pictures taken earlier that evening by his son PJ Monte as a Montauk-Monster.com exclusive.
What’s most disturbing about this discovery is that PJ and Paul’s last name is Monte sharing the well-known nickname for the Montauk Monster, “Monty”. Is this a coincidence or possibly the coming of the apocalypse? In a private conversation with PJ Monte, I mentioned that I had a premonition that our paths would be crossing by the way of the Montauk Monster. Being that this was the first time we had met, I think he was slightly freaked out by that remark. Nonetheless, I had to get that off my chest.
Additionally, the couple who contacted me in May (Monster found in Southhold, NY) made claims that while the dead carcass was in their backyard, (in an ice-filled cooler) the wife had terrible nightmares. They still wish to remain anonymous as the husband disposed of the carcass on a boat ride to Block Island to put his wife at ease. In fear of public humiliation, they wish to keep their identity unknown.
I’m still convinced these creatures are washing up from Plum Island. What do you think?
Tags: doug kennedy montauk monster, geraldo rivera montauk monster, gurney's inn, gurneys inn montauk monster, long island monster, montauk monster apocolypse, montauk monster long island, montauk monster pictures, montauk-monster, montauk-monster.com, montaukmonster.com, monte montauk monster, monty montauk monster, nicky papers, pj monte, plum island, plum island montauk monster



I think the second 2 are fakes due to the publicity of the first ones. i do agree that it has similiar features of a cow but size wise even though the picture doesnt show it well iw would have to be fairly small like maybe even smaller than a calf. Plum island is a god possibility but then again they are probably disposing of bodies properly due the fact that so many people have a problem with animal testing ( i for one do) i cant really say what it is but it definitely is interesting. all i know is in the last picture the skull is way too clean compared to other parts why is the skull so clean considering body fat content. i honestly believe that the last 2 “montauk monsters were placed i mean rally look at the difference in the creatures
I personally think it is a dog that was tossed into the ocean at some point near Montauk to dispose of. Now since there have been more than one appearance it sounds to me like someone is up to no good. Who knows why they may be throwing dogs in, but it appears that they are doing it regularly enough that they show up on Montauks beach. Many of the carcasses probably don’t make it to the beach as they decompose at sea and sink. It could possibly be some experiment gone wrong on Plum Island and was dumped at sea to dispose of. Who really knows? Who REALLY cares?
I for one believe that these things are washing up from Plum Island. Plum Island Animal Disease Center (PIADC) is a United States federal research facility dedicated to the study of animal diseases. It is part of the DHS Directorate for Science and Technology. It’s no secret. A lot of animal experiments are said to go on there as well. It doesn’t EVEN look like an ant eater.
it’s manbearpig… I’m serial
Its an anteater that fell into the water and was carried by currents, probably trying to get at an ants nest on a seaside cliff. If you dont think its probable then go look at one on youtube and look at the skeletal structure of one.
I personally believe this is my mom after getting drunk
This is no racoon, Coon’s have huge fucking canines and this doesnt, so dismiss it as a ‘Coon. Oh hell yes it comes from Plum Island, there are reports of people doing experiments on humans and animals alike at Plum Island and I have no doubt in my mind that this came from there.
if its a raccoon than wat the hell is it doin in the damn ocean plus diff color fur. they all look weird as hell. we got such smart ppl these days. think outside the box not init
I have read FAR too many rants on these comments and to the people who are criticizing the others who say this creature is abnormal SHUT THE FUCK UP! At least we have an imagination! Sure it is probably a raccoon or a dog or whatever but life is better when there is a bit of mystery in it so stop fucking ruining it for the rest of us!
Jeez! -.-
What is the fuss about?? It’s a dog or whatever missing the front of the face… why are people so bored so they make a monster out og this?? Get a life…
sorry to say, but i think its fake because it just looks like a dead cow with its ear snipped and the flesh of the face cut away.
its defiantly a freaking dog. i mean someone probably killed it or something and threw it into the water and now its all gross.
i think it has cow hide and some other animal parts put together ppl do this a lot and do it for publicity and i am not saying it is fake nor real but you would be able to tell if you just took some skin test and inside test and dna if there are not doing this what are they doing with this “thing” i mean if come on use your brain ppl !
thats a dead dog
if its a raccoon its a bloody big one
I agree with Adrian, its a bloated raccoon. Its not a cow, sheep or dog, all you have to do is look at the teeth. Four teeth are missing three premolars and one incisor for meat eaters. Last I remember cows and sheep didn’t eat meat only plants. Teeth of dogs are not like that at all. Also i’m pretty sure everyone here knows cows and sheep do not have claws/toes, they have hooves. This animal has claws of a raccoon, just look at the back leg.What ever everyone wants to beleive it is the teeth don’t lie, those are raccoon teeth.
first its mix with some other thing its dog and something with the mix and it got att by some shark or some thing
looks like a fuck up dog
If it is a monster…..
I think it is a mutated cow?Cuz obiviously there is white and block mark over it…The weird thing is…Why there are fur on some black mark?
If it is another thing……
I also think that it is some animal that we never seen before.But they got some part of cow or u can also say some part from dog…
Like those extincted animal such as a eagle with tiger back?(Bet you guys seen it before)And a Zebra with horse back?
Everyone saying it’s a cow and not a dog, are fucking retarded and they are making total fools of themselves where everyone can see them.
That’s not an udder, that’s it’s stomach about ready to explode.
When a body has been in water for 2+ days, it swells up to twice, maybe three times it’s size. The organs also swell up, making it expand and look like an udder because the top layers of flesh have seriously ripped open.
Take some fucking science classes and look up some dogs.
This is definitely a canine. It appears that some of the teeth were missing, but there are many reasons that dogs would lose teeth, just like people. They’re not bullet proof, either.
Cows don’t have fur like that, they’re not that fluffy.
It appears to be a German Shepard or a Husky crossed with a more common breed. More likely a German Shepard cross, though.
Poor thing got dumped into the water and eaten by fish.
Now everyone thinks it’s a cow or some sort of monster!
I can’t speak for the other ones, I have only seen them once, and I never want to see them again.
But this poor thing is definitely a dog.
Seriously, you guys need to sit down and think about it, and stop making yourselves look like idiots for the sake of arguing.
No Jake, your a Jackass it’s totally your biological mother. Yes, that’s right you were adopted. Sorry to break the news!
et does not ave an utter, mammals ave fur, underr tht they ave a layer off skinn “hide”, th “udder” ish jus et’s insides commin out from decomposision.
et has th skull off a canine.
et has long thick fur.
pointed ears.
muskular legs.
claws/finggers.
not a cow.
also, et’s fur, wolves ave th same thick long fur, normally tht same color tuu.
an th angle they took this photo from, an th distance, et cud jus b a dominat wolf tht has bloated up from th bakteria inside et tht decompose et, an th gases tht built up inside cuz they wernt released b4 th animal died, an wen sumthin dies in ocean, et bloats tu 2, sumtimes 3x et’s normal size.
or, this cud jus b a very very large type off wolf.
i saw one photo off th montauk monster earlyer, et was pettymuch jus an oversized pitbull wiff long teeth.
this aint rockit science.
exkuse ma spellin, am not from amerika.
but rely, ‘m 16, i bet all ya’ll who comment on this b4 me ahre grown edukated adults.
but i also bet ya’ll ahre amerikan, no offenses, but amerikans lik tu belief in wat ish not ethikal or righht.
they thrive off fear, see a large decayed dog, ooohh et simply MUST b a monster!
no, et’s not a monster.
yu can sleep wiff both eyes closed now amerika, Czech saved th day -.-
xDD
Look at a Transylvania Thylacine, a marsupial, thought extinct. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YLXz5ew0tOk
I agree it’s a dead dog. Probably the result of dog fighting. Are there any Dog fighting houses near there? They probably threw the dead dog in the water to get rid of evidence and it washed up. That would explain why there’s been more than 1 found. My guess is, there will be more. “Sad”
Ahem, This is merely a racoon, as one of you remarked “its too huge to be a racoon” anything in the water for more than 3 days will bloat to a possible triple or most likely double it’s size, and dogs have paws yes, cows have hooves yes, but racoons actually have fingers, the skeletal “paw” of a racoon, is exactly the same as the skeletal structure of a babys hand, the fur makes it look bigger and less human. Adressing the matter of the skull, the keiniens and insicors may be missing but the molars, which i add are coninsidently similar to that of a racoons in shape, are in the same exact place.. And again remarking to the pure size of the beast, there is the high chance of them taking the shot in a specific place to make it look larger than it actually is, lastly that flap of skin is most likely muscle that has been bared to fresh air after it’s bloatation causing it to in a sense deflate, it’s leg probably eaten by fish. Or it could also be the after effect of the animals organs strentching it’s skin leaving a thin skin like flap there. Thus your mistery has been solved..
Any remarks or arguments against this will be irrelevant as i have used nothing but whole, true facts. These facts ARE true, nothing said or done shall prove this wrong, no experament nor words will change the arguement displayed, you will only waste your precious time to be proven wrong. There is no excuse for stupidity..
It looks like a dog to me. Everything looks different dead and half eaten. I agree, who is dumping these in the water? This animal looks stocky like a pit bull.
Whatever it is, it looks like it suffered to me….terrible!!! One monster is weird enough, but, another and another….these things are experiments!!! Scary to me…something this unexplainable is just not right!!!
this one looks like a dog. the skull and jaw bone gives it away i dont no about the other two monsters from before but this one is definetly a dog
dudes. you are STUPID! stop bloody arguin over what it is! for all you know it could be some dead mutants that wer made in a government lab or somethin. actually thats a pretty relevant or whatever the word is thing cos that might b why theres no press stuff and all round it cos its government shiz or maybe its a mental geneticist whos not very good at lookin after thier creations. just a thoyught. although it COULD be a large dog lahh….theres a zillion possible answers and 299,9999,99999,999999,999999,999 and so in – are wrong .
Seriously…
Scientific approach:
Fact 1: If you go analyze the particles all around the creature you can see that it’s about 1 feet, maybe 1,5 feet tall, not much bigger and certainly not smaller.
Fact 2: All creatures that live on land and die in water and remain there for a while bloat up. You’ll get 2 to 3 times your current size if it happens to you. That’s why for example drowned humans need to be checked on jaw and dna to be sure it’s a specific person, simply because they’re unrecognizable.
Fact 3: If you look close (just click on the picture and zoom in) you see that the paw is bloated and has toes and nails as well as that the creature has a canine headstructure with the jaw and teeth.
Conclusion: It IS a racoon or anything like it. Stop throwing a fuss, it’s clogging the internet and makes people hope for miracles that aren’t there.
it’s a dog. Look at the sockets for the canine teeth. The ‘udder’ jake, is actually its bloated abdominal organs. Haven’t you ever field dressed an animal? sheesh.
Looks like a mutated cow, guess the aliens were done with it, kinda just dropped it in the water, let a few fish take a bite and hey it just kinda set landfall at the beach…that sounds like some mafia shit right there, them aliens gangsta for real! LMFAO xD. Now for the location…hell they just like that spot, that’s why them ppl was having the wedding at that spot, its a likable spot, them aliens wanted a nice scenery when the was having their way with our livestock
washed up dog. big one too looks like. we need to focus on the sumbitch pushing all the dogs off his boat.
that is so wired and ? it is a alien or a mutated creature.
i think all you guys are wrong it it niether a cow or a dog i know for a fact and proof that its a raccoon
if you click this link –> http://files.abovetopsecret.com/uploads/ats59547_racoon_lat.jpg it shows a real raccoons skull
after yu click the link pay attention to the teeth of the raccoon..now look at the pic you guys call a dog , cow , monster….the back teeth are the same as the pik of the real raccoon skull..but the some of the front teeth are missin…now if ya dumbasses would pay attention ya would of figured it out that its a raccoon…no monster just a dead washed up (prolly got munched on by fish) bloated raccoon!!! point proven
You guys need to relax … first of all this mistery is easy to unfold … anything left in water for more then 2 days or so will bloat up to double or triple it’s size decomposition is normal … and it looks like what i said above.
I believe it’s a dog that has been killed and thrown into the ocean … what does matter tho is that you guys are retarded and thinking it’s a monster and not coming up with a reasonable explanation. Rather jumping to such drastic conclusions.
Take some anatomy classes and some fucking classes on how to not be retarded.
Nonetheless I am done.
And this is ridiculous lmfao.
But for all you kid’s out there, it sure is a monster it came from the deepest of waters couldn’t handle the upper levels of water and it died of to much oxygen LOL.
maybe a dog weird~
This one looks more like a actual animal like a dog little bit more then the first one, and the second one just look at the skull and actually look at other skulls its a dog skull its not like the first one more like someone is pulling leg man.
IT IS NOT A COW NOR A DOG NOR RACCON -i saw all the erick with nok and the first one looks nothing like 2 and 3 because 2 and 3 had there heads like riped off and 3 had one hind leg gone but the idiot scientist r like ohhhhh its just a raccon but forgive me if im wrong butt dude its to huge to be a freakin raccon it also has weird fingers like they were squishy like but a cow has hooves and a dog has paws and so doesa raccon and it it has one ripped up leg and does not have an udder doent have a tail and i have never seen a dog that color before and that long hair
Itis most definitly a dog if you look closley towards the snout of the creature you can see an indent into the skull where the k9 tooth shold be. As for its paws they were porbably knawed on by small to medium size fish. and the deformity was probably from birth .The way the carcass is mangled and shaped is from broken bones and such. I am a veternarian and i see dead dogs that have fallen or been dumped ito the river wash up and look very similar if not almost an exact match to what this dog looks like here.
The jaw on that one looks kind of stange. I’ve never seen anything like it. Have you noticed that all of these “monsters” are in New York? (That just grabbed my attention.) Why is there so little press involved? Do the just not care and rare brushing it off as hoax? I mean come on you would expect this to really big new, wouldn’t you?
It’s a dog, why doesn’t someone look into where these dead dogs are washing in from instead of trying to turn it into the next Bigfoot hoax?
It looks like a goat mixed with a freaking cow if u sen the tails in the other ones it looks like a cow’s tail maybe they are trying to cross breed a goat and a cow???
it is dead cow and thise is body that bactiria eat it :d :d
you know, when decomposition takes place anything can happen.
maybe it’s just a normal animal we see in our everyday life, but just can’t recognize. my so far assumptions are 1st Montauk monster: sloth, 2nd: i’d say some kind of giant seal, otter etc. don’t know anything about the 3rd yet, just think about it. still hope it’s not something out of the ordinary, need a little excitement in my life you know.
that is not a dog you retards ; its not a cow either ; its to big / wide , and its arms are too big to be a dog . it is too small to be a cow , and that thing has claws ; cows have hooves .cows ALSO do NOT have fur like that ..and what the fuck would a COW be doing on a beach . ?actualy not just one cow but four ? stop talking about some poor family , that lost a dog , because it is impossible , that four people lost the exact same kind of dog , on the same beach and it died the same way, or one family lost four of the same dogs ; on the same beach in the same way.. think for a minute people. and also if it was a dog or a raccoon , or a cow . or anything normal , they would have told everybody on the news or wherever the fuck . but instead ; they hid the body , and completely swept it under the rug.. it could be something that mutated .. but how could they make the same mistake three times ? and why would every mistake wwash up in the same place. Seems pretty fuckie to mee .
It’s a dog… i found some kind of this “Monster” in my Italian Vacancies… The water dismantled its fur and the “head” or the skull is the result of hungry fish… the pitbull i found was beaten to death by his owner as he lost a dogfight, an this f**kin’ animal teaser (Is it teaser or torturer? I’m from germany sorry) threw it into the Lago di Garda… nearly one week later i found the “monster” while i was fishing…
It just looks like an abused dog or half eaten dog, that has been in the water for too long, or something x.x no big deal
ITS A CANINE. NOT A MONSTER. IT PROBABLY DID STINK OF ROTTING FLESH. THATS NOT A BEAK BUT THE JAW OF A DOG. YOU CAN SEE WHERE THE TEETH WERE. I CAN SHOW LOTS OF PICS OF ROADKILL AND CALL THEM “MONSTERS”!!!
it looks like a dam cow. the people that said it looked like a dog…open up ur fackin eyes. it has a dam utter. stupid dumbasses….