Just in time for 4th of July weekend, the Montauk Monster has made its return to the shores of Long Island washing up at Gurney’s Inn. (Oceanside resort located in Montauk, NY) The initial discovery was made by PJ Monte and friends while walking on beach property owned by Gurney’s Inn. (July 2nd 2009 at 6:15 PM) The dead and bloated carcass washed up during an elegant oceanfront wedding. With gorgeous views of the Atlantic Ocean it’s no surprise that the Montauk Monster decided to crash the party!
As for the wedding party, the carcass went undetected as PJ Monte and friends moved it to a different location and the photography session began shortly after. Now you are probably wondering how once again I made it to the eye of the storm to cover the breaking news. Allow me to give you the play-by-play.

While on Facebook this evening, I saw an update on PJ Monte’s wall indicating that he found The Montauk Monster as he uploaded photographs to his Flickr account. Yours truly, (Nicky Papers!) is connected to PJ through mutual friends. (God bless social networking!) Within 10 minutes of PJ’s wall posting I was able to get in touch with him by phone and explained that I was interested in covering the story. PJ graciously accepted my wishes and invited me to come out Gurney’s to check it out for myself.
With excitement, I rallied out to Montauk to once again get an up-close-and-personal encounter with the Montauk Monster. Upon arrival at Gurney’s Inn, PJ introduced me to his friends and his father Paul Monte. (General Manager, Gurney’s Inn) Paul Monte led the way as I was taken to a remote part of the property to witness the beast again with my own eyes.
The monster was removed from an ice-filled enclosure and laid out for all to view. The stench this time was so horrific it triggered my gag reflex and I was forced to take a step back. PJ and the crew lifted their shirts over their noses for relief from the rotting stench.
Sure enough, we were all looking at a very similar creature that has now washed up for the fourth documented time by photograph. For those who’ve doubted my discoveries, (Geraldo Rivera, Doug Kennedy) please note that I was with company who have openly revealed themselves and are willing to discuss this incident further.
After the viewing session we loaded the carcass back into the ice-filled enclosure for safe keeping. PJ Monte had to make an early exit as he was on his way to a party that evening in the Hamptons. My discussions with Paul Monte continued with his assistant Kon in an office located on the premises. Paul Monte agreed to run the pictures taken earlier that evening by his son PJ Monte as a Montauk-Monster.com exclusive.
What’s most disturbing about this discovery is that PJ and Paul’s last name is Monte sharing the well-known nickname for the Montauk Monster, “Monty”. Is this a coincidence or possibly the coming of the apocalypse? In a private conversation with PJ Monte, I mentioned that I had a premonition that our paths would be crossing by the way of the Montauk Monster. Being that this was the first time we had met, I think he was slightly freaked out by that remark. Nonetheless, I had to get that off my chest.
Additionally, the couple who contacted me in May (Monster found in Southhold, NY) made claims that while the dead carcass was in their backyard, (in an ice-filled cooler) the wife had terrible nightmares. They still wish to remain anonymous as the husband disposed of the carcass on a boat ride to Block Island to put his wife at ease. In fear of public humiliation, they wish to keep their identity unknown.
I’m still convinced these creatures are washing up from Plum Island. What do you think?
Tags: doug kennedy montauk monster, geraldo rivera montauk monster, gurney's inn, gurneys inn montauk monster, long island monster, montauk monster apocolypse, montauk monster long island, montauk monster pictures, montauk-monster, montauk-monster.com, montaukmonster.com, monte montauk monster, monty montauk monster, nicky papers, pj monte, plum island, plum island montauk monster



the skull is definitely a sheep, the body is probably a sheep as well. the skull has no flesh or meat on it at all, but the body is still completely covered in hair… gimme a break.
Look at the skeletons of the capabarra…a water rodent species that has gone wild in the southern part of the us. It has adapted too well to its new envirnment. It came from argentina . Someone brought it here to breed and sell ,I think for meat. Then let them loose on purpose or not. Capabarra(not sure of the spelling)in argentina have hairy coats….maybe these are mutated or toxin created branches of them???
the skull looks plastic and 2 get a skull that white uve got 2 boil it cuz bones yellow this obviously fake
i am the 4. Monster . You think we are Monsters ? No no we are´nt Monsters. We live at the ground of the ocean .
Definitely some kind of dog. googled ‘dog skull’ and found immediately many very similar skulls. there’s a lot of species and this is probably one of them. If you’re thinking “that doesn’t look like any dog I’ve ever seen!” that is because it’s dead and bloated, and has lost a lot of it’s skin. Dead creatures exposed to water and possibly other creatures feeding off them will look very bad very fast. The fur fits(if it covered the whole body), the skull is almost identical to several types of dogs, and the paws are also very similar, just feel your dogs paws and feel it’s skeleton, identical.
the skull looks fake,its to white and clean.also thats defininatly a dog.the body structure is that of a dog which must have been seriously abused
From the shape & size of the creature, it’s likely too say that this thing that might have been a regular animal isn’t any more, but there’s also a chance that it wasn’t a regular animal too begin with considering the physical anatomy of the creature, I believe that this thing should be considered as one of two things. it should either be classifeied asa a genetic mutation, otherwise known as an experiment gone wrong, or the second option could be that this creature is a failed B.O.W, but at the moment those seem like the only two options
I, for one, agree with John. in my opinion this “new monster” looks like a dog.
it looks like the mouth has severely decomposed a as opposed to the rest of its body. It is some sort of animal we know of, we just can’t tell from the pictures. I think it is a dog with some sort of disease. Its not unlikely.compare it to the pictures of the chupacabra it is what had happened to wild dogs with a severe case of mange.
at first i thought that it was a chupacabra but i took a closer look and thought it was a fox or wolf but then realized that it must be the montauk monster for the idiots out there who think thats a raccon get you f***ing eyes checked
I could write afew hundred paragraphs on why its fake, as real as some parts of it look, but there is a real obvious and stupid reason that shows its fake. If it were real, would we only have one picture of this specific corpse? And wouldnt the scientists be reaserching this thing? Even though if it was real all reserch would be done in private, but scientiss would definatly give some confermation of how fake it was if it was real to keep people from being nosey. AND THINK ABOUT IT! if it was a dog or raccoon or something or even a myserious monster creaure, Do you see anything that proves its adativity to water in his picture? if they all washed up in the same place it would mean they lived there, right? so that takes away the posiblity of an island were it lives that just happens to be undiscoverd. And for anyone with an ‘alien’(losers) claim, it resembles to many well know creatures to from someplace else. Its obiously a fake photo, along with the rest.
First off its a damn dog. The skull is real, and if its not people are retarded and have too much time on their hands to find skulls from one dead animal or a fake skull and then find a decomposing body of a dog and place the skull precisely inside it. And those are not spots, the white is skin, some of the fur has simply washed away. Look more closely. DONE.
I don´t think that it is a racoon, but it can be an animal there is mutatet by radiation and it leavs to another thing. Why is there only found dead montauk´s? And if it is caused by radiation why does they look like each other? It can be a start of a new species. Hwo knows?
ok first of all on the third one. no disrespect to anyone. but. the skull looks like it is made of plastic. secondly just in case i was mistaken. from the body structure it appears to be an abused dog. the stomach is ripped open. the right hind leg has been amputated. the toes on the right front paw have been seriously deformed or adjusted. my guess is that this one is a dog. look very closely at this picture of the 3rd one and a picture of a dog. notice the simular charictiristics of the two. as i said in the begining. i mean no disrespect to the photographer nor to anyone affiliated with this website. that is only my opinion. i will not and can not say if it is real. i can only say what i can see
i think its a buffalo that got ate bye something
If you were actually interested in this animal, you would take your balls out of your back pocket, put some gloves on, and show us this god damn thing at many different angles. Then after you got extensive visual documentation on it, you would bring it to a COLLEGE PROFESSOR who specializes in mammals or whatever category of academia this would fall under, and have him tell you wtf it is.
The very fact that you never seem to actually DIG IN and really intensely investigate this thing, is evidence for anyone with an I.Q. over room temp. that this is all just a bunch of horse shit. If someone really found something like this, you REALLY think they would just LEAVE IT THERE? No, they would take it, bring it somewhere, and try to get credit for finding a new fucking species. You, sir, are full of shit. You know it, and I know it.
I think it IS a dog…maybe it was horribly mutated. Maybe after being born mutated it was found to NOT be resistant to mange. It may have died from another disease and was set to be buried. The tide could have come in and made quicksand out of the place where the creature was buried or washed it out….something to dig up the dead body using waves. Since the scientists thought it was taken care of they wouldn’t go looking for it…
If you’ve ever seen some of the mutations humans go through then you’d realize that either through genetic experimentation or even selective breeding or radiation mutation a dog CAN be altered to look more raccoonish…think about genetically crossing a chihuahua and a raccoon. you can do it in a petrie dish and if you find a suitable surrogate mother you can have it born. Who says it has to live very long?
These are all things to consider…it’s possible that these creatures developed in the wild and haven’t been discovered yet. new species are being discovered every day.
also: cows and goats have hooves. not paws. derp.
it looks like cow mixed with a fox and also mixed with a horse!! ooo its a _____?>>>???
It looks like a goat to me.
anyone take into account that this guy supposedly has been the first to capture all the montauk monsters?
Okay. The first pic clearly has a beak and leathery skin, while the supposed third pic is clearly a cat that has decomped. You can see the skull and the “creature” has teeth and multicolored fur.
when somthing dies the color of the skin whitens plus u dont know how long the animal has been dead if salt water is left on skin or bone it graduly bleaches it to the poimt were it will look like that plus ur hair graduly falls leaving bald spots